H.R.es121 - Supporting the designation of Scouting America Day in celebration of its 115th anniversary. (119th Congress)
Summary
H.Res.121 supports the designation of "Scouting America Day" to celebrate the 115th anniversary of Scouting America (formerly Boy Scouts of America). The resolution recognizes the organization's contributions to youth development, community service, and the instilling of values such as self-reliance, character, and civic leadership.
The resolution highlights Scouting America's history, including its incorporation in 1910, the establishment of a national headquarters, and the granting of a Federal charter by Congress in 1916. It also acknowledges the significant number of youth involved in Scouting and the volunteer hours contributed to communities across the country.
Ultimately, the resolution aims to recognize the positive impact of Scouting America on the development of American citizens who are physically, mentally, and emotionally fit, and prepared to contribute to American society.
Expected Effects
The resolution's passage would formally recognize Scouting America's 115th anniversary with a designated day. This recognition could raise awareness of the organization's activities and contributions.
It may also encourage more youth and adults to participate in Scouting programs. While the resolution itself does not create any new laws or allocate funding, it serves as a symbolic gesture of support from the House of Representatives.
Potential Benefits
- Recognition of Volunteerism: Acknowledges the contributions of adult volunteers who dedicate their time to mentoring youth.
- Promotion of Civic Values: Reinforces the importance of character development, ethical decision-making, and civic leadership among youth.
- Highlighting Community Service: Draws attention to the significant service hours contributed by Scouts to communities nationwide.
- Encouraging Youth Development: Promotes the values and skills taught by Scouting America, such as self-reliance, courage, and resourcefulness.
- Preservation of Heritage: Celebrates the long-standing history and contributions of Scouting America as an American institution.
Most Benefited Areas:
Potential Disadvantages
- Potential for Exclusivity Concerns: Historically, Scouting America (formerly Boy Scouts of America) has faced criticism regarding inclusivity, particularly related to gender and sexual orientation, although there have been policy changes to address these concerns. This resolution might be seen as overlooking these past issues by some.
- Lack of Tangible Impact: The resolution is largely symbolic and does not guarantee any concrete benefits or resources for Scouting America or the communities it serves.
- Opportunity Cost: Congressional time and resources spent on this resolution could potentially be directed towards addressing other pressing issues.
- Risk of Over-Glorification: The resolution may present an overly positive view of Scouting America, without acknowledging any potential shortcomings or areas for improvement.
- Limited Scope: The resolution focuses solely on Scouting America, potentially overlooking other youth development organizations that also contribute to the well-being of American communities.
Constitutional Alignment
The resolution appears to align with the general principles of the US Constitution, particularly the Preamble's goal to "promote the general Welfare" by supporting youth development and community service. It does not infringe upon any specific constitutional rights or provisions.
However, some might argue that government endorsement of a specific organization could potentially raise concerns under the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which prohibits government endorsement of religion, given Scouting America's historical association with religious organizations. However, the resolution itself does not explicitly promote any religious viewpoint.
Overall, the resolution's alignment with the Constitution is generally positive, as it supports a non-profit organization that contributes to the development of responsible and engaged citizens.
Impact Assessment: Things You Care About ⓘ
This action has been evaluated across 19 key areas that matter to you. Scores range from 1 (highly disadvantageous) to 5 (highly beneficial).